April 04, 2018

Darcs News

Darcs 2.14.0 released

April 04, 2018 03:04 PM UTC

The Darcs team is pleased to announce the release of Darcs 2.14.0!

Darcs is a free, open source revision control system. It is:

Learn more about Darcs on .

Supported GHC and Cabal versions

Darcs 2.14 can be compiled with GHC 8.0, 8.2 and 8.4, and
supports Cabal versions from 1.24.

Windows issues

Darcs 2.14 received many updates in its support of encoding.
However, it may still contain bugs, especially under Windows,
a platform for which we have fewer known users. Please let us
know if you encounter weird behaviour under Windows.

What's new

User Interface:

New features:



Issues resolved in Darcs 2.14:

July 26, 2017

Darcs News

Darcs News #114

July 26, 2017 02:35 PM UTC

News and discussions

  1. Since the first release of Darcs 2.12, we released a few minor versions, the latest being 2.12.5 on January:
  2. Ben Franksen and Gian Piero Carrubba performed some refactorings about Darcs (zsh) autocompletion:
  3. As for Darcsden, the backend of, progress has been made on modernizing the ssh server used by it:

Issues resolved (7)

issue2138 Guillaume Hoffmann
issue2496 Ben Franksen
issue2498 Ganesh Sittampalam
issue2504 Ben Franksen
issue2512 Stephan-A. Posselt
issue2516 Ben Franksen
issue2526 Ben Franksen

Patches applied (196)

See darcs wiki entry for details.

September 05, 2016

Darcs News

darcs 2.12.1 release

September 05, 2016 08:17 PM UTC

The Darcs team is pleased to announce the release of Darcs 2.12.1!

The most important changes are:

This release can be installed via cabal or (soon) stack. The 2.12 branch is also available as a darcs repository from .

April 29, 2016

Darcs News

darcs 2.12.0 release

April 29, 2016 03:20 PM UTC

The Darcs team is pleased to announce the release of Darcs 2.12.0.


One way of installing Darcs 2.12.0 is with stack:

$ stack install darcs-2.12.0

Or first install the Haskell Platform (
and install Darcs with cabal-install:

$ cabal update
$ cabal install darcs-2.12.0

You can also download the tarball from and build it by hand.

The 2.12 branch is also available as a darcs repository from

What's new

Patch dependency graph export

The new command `darcs show dependencies`, enables to export the dependency graph of a repository (up to the latest tag, by default) as a Graphviz file:

whatsnew output and third-party VC frontend support

The flag `whatsnew --machine-readable` is a simplified version of `whatsnew -s` for easier parsability by third-party tools. Darcs 2.12 adds conflict markers to the output of whatnew when summarized (ie, when used with the `-s` or `--machine-readable` flags or via the `darcs status` alias). Thanks to this, Darcs support was reintroduced in meld 3.15.2 .

improvements for Git repository imports

File moves are converted to file moves primitives, instead of being file deletes and add as before. This enables to have smaller Darcs respositories with a more understandable history. This change adds to other improvements and fixes that make Git import more practical.

repository Weak Hashes

The command `darcs show repo` now shows a hash that is the XOR
of all hashes of the patches metadata of the repository. Being a XOR,
it does not depend on the patches' ordering. Also it is quite fast to
calculate. This Weak Hash can be useful to quickly check whether two
repositories of a single proyect have the same patches.

April 15, 2016

Darcs News

Darcs News #113

April 15, 2016 03:02 PM UTC

News and discussions

  1. We will release Darcs 2.12 by the end of this month:
  2. On May 6th-8th in Helsinki, a joint sprint Pijul/Darcs is organized:

Issues resolved (5)

issue1807 Guillaume Hoffmann
issue2258 Guillaume Hoffmann
issue2393 Guillaume Hoffmann
issue2486 Ben Franksen
issue2494 Ben Franksen

Patches applied (96)

2016-04-14 Guillaume Hoffmann
  • move network-related tests to network dir, update command names
  • resolve issue2393: remove whatsnew functionality from annotate
  • add log --machine-readable to see patch dependencies non-interactively
  • help of log
2016-04-01 Ganesh Sittampalam
  • add some doc comments to RepoType
2016-03-29 Guillaume Hoffmann
  • merge Repository.Util into Repository.State
  • use B and BC instead of BS and BSC in Repository.State
  • fix prelude import in Repository.State
  • move maybeApplyToTree to Darcs.Patch.Apply
  • move getRecursiveDarcsRepos to UI.Commands.Optimize
  • move patchSetfMap to Darcs.Patch.Set
  • move functions from Repository.Util to Patch.TokenReplace
  • comment in Repository.Util
  • refactor similar functions in Darcs.Repository.State
  • use readUnrecordedFiltered in getReplaces
  • inline a function in Clone
  • no longer move index to index.old on mingw32 os
  • clarify comments in Darcs.Repository.State
  • hlint Darcs.Repository.State
  • move External module from Repository to Util
  • move Compat and Lock modules from Repository to Util
  • merge Darcs.Repository.Ssh into Darcs.Util.Ssh
  • remove Darcs.Repository.Read by moving readRepo back to Internal
  • add comments and remove checks of optimize commands wrt repo formats
  • make all optimize subcommands require hashed except upgrade
  • move copySources from HashedRepo to Clone
  • move Storage.Hashed modules to Darcs.Util
  • remove unused function from Storage.Hashed.Plain
  • fix compile error in Storage.Hashed.Test
  • remove Storage.Hashed.Utils, move functions to Darcs.Utils.ByteString
  • move index-related functions from Utils to Index
  • removed unused or redundant functions from Storage.Hashed.Utils
  • remove unused functions from Storage.Hashed.Hash
  • hlint Storage.Hashed.Darcs
  • reuse functions from Darcs.Util.Path
  • remove unused Storage.Hashed.Packs
2016-03-09 Ben Franksen
  • revert command: be quiet when requested
  • accept issue2480: display unicode in patch content
  • slightly improved chaotic indentations and import lists
  • refactor: use maybeRestrictSubpaths
  • refactor: use Darcs.Util.English.capitalize
  • replace Darcs.Util.Printer.<> with <> from Data.Monoid; restructured haddocks
  • small code layout fix in whatsnew command
  • fixed Darcs.Util.English.andClauses and orClauses
  • two simple refactorings in the conflict resolution code
  • cleanup in revert command: use debugMessage for debug messages
  • cleanup: break over-long line in D.R.Merge
  • accept issue2494: output of darcs record with file arguments
  • resolve issue2494: output of darcs record with file arguments
  • refactored some, added readUnrecordedFiltered and maybeRestrictSubpaths
  • several fixes and refactorings in fixSubPaths and maybeFixSubPaths
  • add Darcs.Util.Printer.quoted and Darcs.Util.Text.pathlist
  • added missing hsep function to D.Util.Printer
  • added missing Eq and Show instances for ScanKnown
  • added Darcs.Util.Printer.ePutDocLn
  • add new type IncludeBoring for includeBoring option (was Bool)
  • announceFiles only if verbosity /= Quiet
2016-03-05 Guillaume Hoffmann
  • rm hashed-storage changelog
  • put copyright headers in hashed-storage modules
  • add Storage/Hashed dir to checkdeps contrib script
  • merge Storage.Hashed.AnchoredPath into Darcs.Util.Path
  • explicit exports for Storage.Hashed.Utils
  • list and comment exports of Storage.Hashed.Darcs and Plain
  • remove Storage.Hashed
  • resolve issue2258: improve patch index error message with suggestion
  • resolve issue1807: clarify help of PAGER, DARCS_PAGER
  • fix extra-source-file path in darcs.cabal
2016-03-07 Ben Franksen
  • Darcs.UI.Commands.Unrecord: honor quiet option everywhere
  • resolve issue2486: obliterate --not-in-remote -q should be more quiet
2016-02-25 Ganesh Sittampalam
  • print the rebase status even after an error
  • in runJob, pull repojob out to first-level decision
  • refactor displaying suspended status a bit
  • inline repoJobOnRebaseRepo
  • use helper types to elide more cases in runJob
  • elide some common cases in runJob
  • reorder runJob cases by job type
  • flatten runJob case statements
  • add a helper type for flags needed for Rebase
  • lift the runJob debugMessage call outside the case
  • lift 'therepo' outside the runJob case statement
  • express the V1/V2 patch type switch via a GADT too
  • use SRepoType to control the rebase type in runJob
  • remove commented-out cases for old TreeJob
  • drop unnecessary constraints
  • break out a runJob function
  • drop CarrierType - it can't ever be Rebasing p now
  • drop RecontextRebase
  • drop NameHack
  • inline MaybeInternal module into Named.Wrapped
  • make the Rebase import qualified
  • Introduce RebaseP to replace Rebasing type
  • add 'activecontents' to replace 'patchcontents' for use in conflict resolution
  • stop Convert using Wrapped.patchcontents
  • add nullary RepoType
  • flip dependency between Named.Wrapped and Rebase.Container
  • add wrapper type around 'Named'
See darcs wiki entry for details.

April 03, 2016

Darcs News

Darcs News #112

April 03, 2016 08:29 PM UTC

News and discussions

  1. After 7 years of being the maintainer/Benevolent Dictator of Darcs, Eric Kow stepped down and offered me (Guillaume Hoffmann) to take over, which I accepted:
  2. The release process of Darcs 2.12 will start when GHC 8 is released:
  3. We had two new minor releases of Darcs 2.10, and in spite of being minor, they contain a few interesting changes and optimizations:
  4. In a span of 4 months we had two sprints, one in Paris in September and another another in Seville in January, check out the reports:
  5. Finally, Pierre-Étienne Meunier announced a Pijul sprint in may in Finland. Darcs hackers are welcome!

Issues resolved (7)

issue2269 Eric Kow
issue2276 Eric Kow
issue2400 Ben Franksen
issue2459 Ben Franksen
issue2479 Ben Franksen
issue2481 Ganesh Sittampalam
issue2489 Guillaume Hoffmann

Patches applied (176)

2016-03-26 Sergei Trofimovich
  • allow zip-archive-0.3
2016-03-22 Guillaume Hoffmann
  • remove failing-issue1609 from testsuite as property we don't want
2016-03-06 Ben Franksen
  • move command: fixed punctuation of error messages and added a comment
  • use bug from impossible.h instead of error
  • cleanup in Darcs.Patch.Merge: use case instead of fromJust (do return ...)
2016-02-12 Ganesh Sittampalam
  • Get rid of the need for DummyPatch in Darcs.Patch.Match
2016-03-05 Guillaume Hoffmann
  • move to root and update to run outside of testsuite
2016-02-12 Ganesh Sittampalam
  • drop re-exports from Darcs.Patch.Rebase
  • abstract out checking whether a Named is internal
  • add versions of simplifyPush[es] for Suspended
  • move addFixup to Rebase.Container and give it a clearer name
  • add Repair instance for Suspended
  • Ignore the rebase internal patch when showing dependencies
  • simplify instance ShowPatchBasic (RebaseSelect p)
  • break out PatchInspect instance for Suspended
  • rename mkSuspended to mkRebase and make it work on 'Suspended'
  • use Suspended instead of FL RebaseItem in takeRebase
  • break out RepairToFL instance for Suspended
  • break out ReadPatch instance for Suspended
  • break out Check instance for Suspended
  • break out Show instances for Suspended
  • break out Conflict instance for Suspended
  • break out Effect instance for Suspended
  • add PrimPatchBase instance for Suspended
  • break out ShowPatch instance for Suspended
  • break out Apply instance for Suspended
  • refactor instance ShowPatch Rebasing a bit
  • inline a couple of defaults to simplify future refactoring
  • abstract out an instance ShowPatchBasic Suspended
  • Introduce a 'Suspended' type to encapsulate 'FL RebaseItem'
2016-03-18 Ben Franksen
  • skip ssh tests if ssh server is down
  • made network ssh tests more robust by passing --skip-long-comment
  • fix ssh network tests so they work in the test harness
  • skip http network tests when server does not respond
  • run network tests by default
  • resolve issue2479: root dir most not be among the sources of a move
  • accept issue2479: bug descending in modifyTree
2016-03-08 Guillaume Hoffmann
  • update failing-issue2219
  • acknowledge that issue1196 is solved
  • acknowledge a working case in
  • merge HACKING into
2016-02-17 Ganesh Sittampalam
  • get rid of a couple of trailing newlines
2016-02-05 Guillaume Hoffmann
  • remove unused executable and testsuite dependencies
  • comment in cabal file workaround
  • group all non-optional build-depends
  • remove unused darcs-test dependencies
  • comment use of flag REENTRANT
  • drop definition of HAVE_SIGINFO_H unused since 2009
  • hlint Darcs.Util.Diff.Patience
  • format patch names within 20 characters in dependencies output
  • show dependencies up to last tag by default
  • further merge hashed-storage code and tests into darcs code
  • bump second html dependency
  • darcs show dependencies
  • implement function getDeps
2016-01-28 Ganesh Sittampalam
  • fix git test involving deletions
2016-01-25 Guillaume Hoffmann
  • handle file moves and copies when importing from git
  • recommend using -M flag on git fast-export
  • tests related to git import of file moves
  • use F and T instead of From and To in whatsnew --machine-readable
  • bump dependencies lower bounds implied by requiring ghc 7.6
  • 2.10.3 changelog
2016-01-29 Ganesh Sittampalam
  • support transformers-compat 0.5.x
2016-01-25 Guillaume Hoffmann
  • avoid irrefutable pattern when importing unnamed commit
  • test for deleting empty directories on git import
  • delete empty directories on git import
  • rollback filename dequoting on import since now done during parsing
  • quoting and escaping of filenames in convert export and import
  • test for checking filepaths consistency with git
  • resolve issue2489: dequote filepaths while importing from git
2016-01-28 Ganesh Sittampalam
  • fix tests that use "git commit"
  • applyToTree is just a specialisation of applyToState
  • drop unnecessary constraint
  • simplify type
  • drop unused (and never defined) putApplyState
  • move the ObjectMap related code to the FileUUID patch type
  • disentangle the state-specific ApplyMonad methods
  • swap argument order to ApplyMonad/ApplyMonadTrans
  • Rename Prim.V3 to Prim.FileUUID
  • move listConflictedFiles out of Conflict class
  • Get rid of default implementation of conflictedEffect
  • Add some tests for how conflicts are reported
  • Drop an unnecessary call to patchcontents in applyAndFix
  • Drop unnecessary use of patchcontents in hunkmatch and touchmatch
2016-01-16 Guillaume Hoffmann
  • rename Patch and RealPatch to RepoPatchV1 and RepoPatchV2 in harness
  • rename Patch and RealPatch to RepoPatchV1 and RepoPatchV2 in darcs code
  • do not open patches uselessly when no file restriction given
  • add Darcs.Test.Patch.Selection and one unit test
  • convert import should be a RepoJob, not a V2Job
  • replace TaggedPatch by LabelledPatch in a comment
  • whatsnew --machine-readable help string update on file moves
  • --machine-readable flag for more parseable whatsnew
  • fix code inside of a comment
2016-01-16 Ganesh Sittampalam
  • resolve conflicts between changes to splitters and to hijacking
  • capture diffAlgorithm in splitters instead of passing it to SelectChanges unconditionally
  • drop unneeded export
  • simplify the PatchInspect (Rebasing p) instance
  • implement hunkMatches for PatchInfoAnd
  • move Rebasing out into its own module
  • break RebaseItem out into its own file
  • bump async dependency
  • conditionalise a couple of orphan instances
  • resolve conflict in build-tools removal
  • drop build-tools restriction
  • Bump time, HTTP dependencies
2016-01-15 Guillaume Hoffmann
  • set use-time-1point5 flag default to True to please stack
  • disable interfering env variable in issue1739 test
  • rename README to to get it properly rendered
2016-01-15 Ganesh Sittampalam
  • resolve conflict between binary version bump and containers dep
  • bump binary, transformers and tar upper bounds
2016-01-14 Guillaume Hoffmann
  • make commit an alias for record
  • implement repoXor and show it in "show repo" output as "Weak Hash"
2015-12-28 Ganesh Sittampalam
  • Portability fix - #type nl_item isn't always Int32
  • add test that lost deps during rebase are reported on
  • remove unused fmapPIAP
2015-12-22 Guillaume Hoffmann
  • fix repo upgrade help string
2015-12-02 Ganesh Sittampalam
  • resolve issue2481: expose API for 'darcs diff' command
2015-11-20 Guillaume Hoffmann
  • remove a flag needed only for GHC < 7
  • remove -fno-warn-dodgy-imports from modules that were still using it
  • no longer hide catch from Prelude since we require ghc>=7.6
  • acknowledge -fno-warn-dodgy-imports is always needed
  • merge Darcs.Patch.ConflictMarking into Darcs.Patch.Conflict
2015-11-29 Ganesh Sittampalam
  • bump dependencies on vector, process, HUnit
  • force grep to treat output of locale as text
2015-11-20 Guillaume Hoffmann
  • Rename Darcs.Repository.LowLevel to Darcs.Repository.Pending
2012-08-09 Eric Kow
  • Haddock the pending patch parts of Darcs.Repository.State.
  • Make Darcs.Repository.isSimple apply over a whole list.
2015-11-09 Guillaume Hoffmann
  • rename NEWS to CHANGELOG to please hackagedb
  • fix release date of 2.10.2
  • update NEWS for 2.10.1 and 2.10.2
  • fix two tests after stopping using the word changes in pull message
  • shorter README with quickstart instructions
2015-11-06 Ganesh Sittampalam
  • add comments about the rejected 'hasDuplicate' cases
  • "Fix" some intermittent QuickCheck failures
  • disambiguate imports in some test code
  • Add an option to control the number of QuickCheck iterations
  • make test-framework imports explicit
2015-11-05 Guillaume Hoffmann
  • refactor breakAfterNthNewline and breakBeforeNthNewline
  • refactor clone code
  • download patches pack asynchronously
  • ignore meta- files in packs when cloning
  • comment in doOptimizeHTTP
2015-06-28 Ben Franksen
  • remove race from D.R.Packs, further simplify the code
2015-10-31 Guillaume Hoffmann
  • replace changes by log in
  • remove file from 2008
  • replace changes by log in Setup.lhs
  • update upload.cgi with new command names
  • update with new command names
  • update cygwin-wrapper file with new commands names and flags
  • remove annotate xml schema no longer needed
  • remove patch index correctness and timing scripts from contrib
  • adapt tests to using patches word instead of changes
  • update commands names in help strings
2015-10-28 Ganesh Sittampalam
  • split issue1932 test up into a network and non-network part
  • Avoid subshells in amend-unrecord test
  • disable issue2086 test on Windows - umasks don't really work there
  • using mmap on Windows was causing test failures
  • warn when suspending "hijacked" patches in rebase pull and apply
  • be a bit clearer about patch names in hijack test
2015-09-20 Eric Kow
  • resolve issue2269: push hijack test to suspend time
  • resolve issue2276: Keep track of patch hijack decisions
  • Generalise hijack warning to support use in other commands
  • Helper to capitalize a sentence
2015-06-24 Ben Franksen
  • resolve issue2459: fall back to writing the file if createLink fails
  • resolve issue2400: use async package to keep track of unpack threads
  • removed special handling of --to-match from cloneRepository
2015-10-16 Guillaume Hoffmann
  • remove redundant import
2015-10-15 Ganesh Sittampalam
  • drop sandi lower bound to support GHC 7.4 and add an upper bound
2015-10-03 Daniil Frumin
  • Switch from dataenc (deprecated) to sandi
2015-10-09 Guillaume Hoffmann
  • replace changes by log in two help strings
2015-09-18 Eric Kow
  • Refactor darcs send patch count text snippet
  • Tidy darcs send msg code (shorter lines)
  • Fix typo in darcs send message
2015-09-19 Guillaume Hoffmann
  • make patch selection lazier in presence of matchers
  • get rid of selectChanges
  • inline patchSetToPatches in the only place where it is used
See darcs wiki entry for details.

January 18, 2016

Darcs News

darcs hacking sprint 10 report

January 18, 2016 04:57 PM UTC

Last weekend we had our tenth Darcs sprint, and our first one in Spain. This time indeed, the sprint was organised in the University of Seville, ETSII (Technical Superior School of Informatics Engineering), on January 15th to 17th.

We were 3 participants: Florent Becker, Guillaume Hoffmann and Ganesh Sittampalam. We also had Pierre-Étienne Meunier on video call and Simon Michael on IRC.

Darcs and Pijul integration

One major topic during the whole sprint was the possible integration of Darcs with Pijul. Pijul is a new version control system based on a different patch theory, whose main author is Pierre-Étienne Meunier. Florent also contributes to Pijul and announced its first release last October.

Pijul is promising in terms of how it handles conflicts in a better way than Darcs (better as: better presentation to the user and better performance). There may be a future where Darcs uses Pijul patches by default.  We had many conversations with Florent to understand the internals of Pijul and how it manages patches.

On the first day of the sprint we did a video call with Pierre-Étienne Meunier, to discuss integration of Pijul core with Darcs. It happens that the Darcs code is modular enough to handle Pijul patches (with some work). That afternoon Florent started to work on a Haskell binding for libpijul (through a C binding maintained by Pierre-Étienne, Pijul being implemented in Rust).

Ganesh, Florent and Pierre-Étienne are going to work towards a better integration of both systems. Pierre-Étienne plans to release a 0.2 version of Pijul soon.

Ganesh and Florent with Pierre-Étienne on video call

Renaming Patch/RealPatch to RepoPatchV1/RepoPatchV2

The code of Darcs contains many different layers of patch types. One of them is represented by the two types Patch and RealPatch, and specifies the behaviour of named patch when they are commuted and in case of conflicts. The "Patch" type is the behaviour of patches in repositories with the darcs-1 patch semantics (which can still be created by Darcs) and "RealPatch" is for darcs-2 semantics (the current default of Darcs). I sent a patch to rename these types into something less confusing: RepoPatchV1 and RepoPatchV2.

Interactive selection performance and refactoring

Even if we wrote a patch that improved greatly performance during the last sprint (and we now have a unit test for it), the command "darcs rollback -p ." still remains much slower than "darcs rollback" before presenting the first choice of patch to the user. Florent determined that this was because the action of matching patches within interactive selection is not lazy, ie, the whole list of patches has to be scanned and classified before the first prompt is shown to the user. Florent unearthed a refactor he had of the patch selection code and started rebasing it against the current code.

User manual and developer handbook

We want Darcs to have a user manual again, and a developer handbook that would compile documentation for programmers and computer scientists. We decided the manual should live in darcs' repository itself (so that it stays up-to-date) and the developer handbook on the wiki.

Darcs on Stackage

On IRC, Simon Michael (after an initial request by Joachim Breitner) committed himself to maintain a stack.yaml file for Darcs, and during the weekend Darcs was added to stackage for easier building.

Cleanup, fixes and refactorings

Ganesh tracked down bugs in rebase and sent a few cleanup patches. Moreover he's improving the code of "darcs test" (formerly called "darcs trackdown") so that uncompilable states are neither considered as Passing nor Failing, and bisect is going to be more efficient.

What happens next

I am going to release Darcs 2.10.3 within a couple of weeks, and Darcs 2.12 within a couple of months. This new major version will have optimizations (some of them are already backported to the 2.10 branch) and code refactorings. It may contain the stash feature currently developed by Ganesh. 

This year we hope to have another sprint, and to have more developers participating. Please consult the How to Help, Developer's Getting Started and Projects page on the wiki to get involved!

Ganesh, Florent and Guillaume

September 24, 2015

Darcs News

darcs hacking sprint 9 report

September 24, 2015 03:35 PM UTC

After a one year and a half absence, the Darcs Hacking Sprint returned!

Once again, the event occurred at the IRILL (Innovation and Research Initiative for Free Software) in Paris, on September 18th to 20th.

The sprint had 7 participants: Danill Frumin, Eric Kow, Florent Becker, Ganesh Sittampalam, Guillaume Hoffmann, Thomas Miedema and Vinh Dang.

Darcs and GHC 8

Thomas Miedema is a Haskell and GHC hacker, and came on the first day of the sprint. Since Darcs is a system that aims at supporting the various GHC versions out there, Thomas helped us preparing for GHC 8, the next major version. He explained us one issue of GHC 8 that got triggered by Darcs: a bug with the PatternSynonyms extension. Fortunately it seems that the bug will be fixed in GHC HEAD. (First release candidate is planned for December).

Thomas explaining PatternSynonyms to Eric and Ganesh

Diving into SelectChanges and PatchChoices code

On the first day I (Guillaume) claimed the "rollback takes ages" bug, which made me look into SelectChanges and PatchChoices code. The result is that I still haven't yet fixed the bug, but I discovered that patch matching was unnecessarily strict, which I could fix easily. Internally, there are two interesting patch types when it comes to matching:
Now, getting the NamedPatch for some patch is then obviously more costly than a PatchInfoAnd. You may even have to download the patch file in order to read it (in the case of lazy repositories). Moreover,  the majority of matchers only need the patch info (or metadata), not its actual contents. Only two matchers (hunk and touch) need to actually read the patch file, while matching or a patch name for instance (probably the most common operation) does not.

So, before the sprint, as soon as you wanted to match on a patch file, you had to open (and maybe download) its file, even if this was useless. With my change (mostly in Darcs.Patch.Match) we gained a little more laziness; and the unreasonably slow command "rollback -p ." passes from 2 minutes to ~15 seconds on my laptop. I hope to push this change into Darcs 2.10.2.

Eric, Guillaume and Vinh

Now, the real source of the "rollback -p ." slowness is that patch selection is done on FL's (Forward List), while commands like rollback and obliterate naturally work backwards in time on RL. Currently, an RL is inverted and then given to the patch selection code, which is not convenient at all! Moreover, the actual representation of history of a Darcs repository is (close to being) an RL. So it seems like a proper fix for the bug is to generalize the patch selection code to also work on RL's; which may involve a good amount of typeclass'ing in the relevant modules. I think this will be too big/risky to port to the 2.10 branch, so it will wait for Darcs 2.12.

Ganesh's new not-yet-officially-named stash command

A few days before the sprint, Ganesh unveiled his "stash" branch. It feature a refactoring that enables to suspend patches (ie, put them into a state such that they have no effect in the working copy) but without changing their identity (which is currently what occurs with the darcs rebase command). This enables to implement a git-stash-like feature.

The sprinters (IRL and on IRC) discussed the possible name of the command that should encapsulate this stash feature. More importantly, on the last day we discussed what would be the actual UI of such a feature. As always when a new feature is coming to darcs, we want to make the UI as darcsy as possible :-)

Coming back to the code, Ganesh's refactoring, if extensive, will also simplify the existing types for suspended patches. We decided to go with it.

Dan's den

Dan demonstrating den (on the left: Florent)
Daniil Frumin was this years Google Summer of Code student for Darcs. Mentored by Ganesh, he brought improvements to Darcsden, many of them being already deployed. Among them, it is possible to launch a local instance of Darcsden (using an executable called den), not unlike Mercurial's "serve" command.

Dan tells more about his work and this sprint in his latest blog post.

A better website and documentation

As a newcomer to the project, Vinh took a look at the documentation, especially the website of the project. He implemented changes to make the front page less intimidating and more organized. He also had a fresh look at our "quickstart" and proposed improvements which we felt were much needed!

Florent's projects

For this sprint, Florent was more an external visitor than a Darcs hacker. He talked about one of his current projects: Pijul, a version control system with another approach. Check out their website!

Conclusion and the next sprint

In the end this sprint turned out to be more productive and crowded than we initially thought! It has been a lot of time since the previous one, so we had a lot of things to share at first. Sprints do make synchronization between contributors more effective. They are also a moment when we can get more concentrated on the Darcs codebase, and spend more time tacking some issue.

Avenue d'Italie, Paris
We would like to thank the IRILL people for hosting the sprint for the third time and our generous donators to make travelling to sprints easier.

We already have a time and a place for the next sprint: Sevilla, Spain in January 2016! The exact moment will be announced later, but you can already start organizing yourself and tell us if you're going.

Thomas, Eric and Ganesh
From left to right: Vinh, Florent, Dan, Ganesh and Eric

Dan Frumin

Darcsden improvements and Darcs sprint

September 24, 2015 01:06 PM UTC

This post is intended to be a short summary of my SoC project, as well as my recent trip to Darcs sprint.


I am finishing up this post on the train back from the Autumn 2015 Darcs sprint. Today (Sept 20, Sun) was a very fun day full of darcs chatting and coding. By the end of the day we’ve heard a number of presentations

Looking back

I have spent this summer hacking on DarcsDen as part of the Google Summer of Code program.

My basic goal was to create a "local" version of darcsden. It was not a trivial task to install darcsden (and probably installation is still not very easy!). It uses a third-party software like Redis and CouchDB. During my coding process I modifed darcsden such that it now can be a good choice for local (or lightweight single user) darcs UI. The local darcsden version can be used without any databases, tracking the repositories in the local file system. This way darcsden can be used by a developer on her local computer, like darcsum, (for working with/comparing repositories) as well as a replacement for darcsweb/cgit — a single user web front for darcs repositories.

Besides that a user of a local version can use darcsden’s interactive UI for recording new patches, as well as a command-line tool den for a quick way of browsing the repositories.

Installing darcsden-local is currently not as easy as I want to it be, but I hope that soon you will be able to install it just by running cabal install darcsden or brew install darcsden. As for now, one could do the following:

  1. darcs get --lazy
  2. cabal install . or stack install

This should install the darcsden binary and all the related css/js files. You can start darcsden by running darcsden --local. If you open your web browser you should see a list of repositories in the current directory.

However, you might have repositories scattered all over the place, and scanning your whole system for darcs repositories is just inefficient. For this purposes darcs keeps a list of repositories in a file inside your ~/.darcs directory. You can manage that list either by hand, or using the command-line den tool:

In order to further customize darcsden, one can tweak the configuration file located at ~/.darcs/darcsden.conf. Apart from the usual darcsden settings one may pay attention to the following variables:

The user/password credentials are required for editing the repositories and recording new patches. However, the den binary should automatically pick them up from the config file and log you in.

Once you are logged in, and you have unrecorded changes in the repository, you can use darcsden UI to record a new patch.

DarcsDen record

DarcsDen record

Below you can see an example of recording and merging patches from a branch.

DarcsDen merge

DarcsDen merge

Darsden allows you to create forks/branches of your repositories, and it keeps track of the patch dependencies in your branches.

More "internal" changes:

What now?

During the sprint I hacked together some code for viewing suspended patches along the regular ones. The next step would be to have a similar interface for managing the suspended patches.

We have also discussed the possibility of adding rewrite rules implementing short-cut fusion for the directed types in Darcs. In order to see if it’s really worth it we would have to bring back to life the benchmarking suite (or at least check on it!).

It was a really exciting weekend for me and I was delighted to meet some of my IRC friends. As it turns out, it is a small world and despite being from different parts of it we have a bunch of common IRL friends, professors. As the French would (probably not) say, très bien. The next darcs sprint will probably be in January, and probably in Europe, again.

September 20, 2015

Dan Frumin

Darcs internals, part 1: typesafe directed datastructures

September 20, 2015 10:22 AM UTC

I am editing this post from IRILL, where the darcs sprint is taking place

One of the things that I particularly like about the Darcs codebase is that you can see that the developers were not shy about using intermediate-slash-advanced Haskell/GHC features to help achieving type safety. You can see GADTs, associated types, phantom types, existential types actively used.

In this post I would like to discuss the representation of patches and the use of type witnesses in darcs.

A word about patches and contexts

This post is intended for people interested in patch theory and its implementation in darcs. A passing familiarity with patches, contexts, inverses, etc is useful, but not required, as we restate some basic definitions in this section.

A primitive patch is a basic unit in patch theory. It constitutes an atomic change in the repository. The definition of a primitive patch may vary, but usually the following changes are considered primitive patches:

Every primitive patch has a pre-context and a post-context. Roughly, you can think of a pre-context as the full state of the repository before the change was made, and of the post-context as the full state of the repository after the change was applied. We write (x)-A->(y) for a patch A with a pre-context x and a post-context y.

If a primitive patch A has a pre-context a, a post-context o, and a primitive patch B has a pre-context o, a post-context b, then we can combine two patches to obtain a sequential patch AB with the pre-context a and the post-context b.

Every primitive patch (x)-A->(y) has an inverse (y)-A^{-1}->(x), such that (x)-A->(y)-A^{-1}->(x) is equivalent to the identity patch (x)-1->(x).

In the next sections we will see how those things are implemented in darcs.

Primitive patches and witnesses

A primitive patch, which constitutes a single fine grained change, can be represented as a (G)ADT:

data Prim where
    Move :: FileName -> FileName -> Prim
    RmFile :: FileName -> Prim
    AddFile :: FileName -> Prim
    Hunk :: FileName -> Int -> ByteString -> ByteString -> Prim
    RmDir :: FileName -> Prim

We can represent complex patches as sequences of primitive patches:

data Patch where
    NilP :: Patch
    PrimP :: Prim -> Patch
    SeqP :: Patch -> Patch -> Patch

This seems reasonable enough. But if we implement our patch theory this way we seem to be missing something — patches have (pre- and post-) contexts. Having contexs allows us to enforce patch composition on the level of type system. Consider the following definition, which uses phantom types as type witnesses for contexts.

data Prim x y where
    Move :: FileName -> FileName -> Prim x y
    RmFile :: FileName -> Prim x y
    AddFile :: FileName -> Prim x y
    Hunk :: FileName -> Int -> ByteString -> ByteString -> Prim x y
    RmDir :: FileName -> Prim x y

data Patch x y where
    NilP :: Patch x x
    PrimP :: Prim x y -> Patch x y
    SeqP :: Patch x y -> Patch y z -> Patch x z

We call the types with witnesses representing pre- and post-contexts directed types. Intuitively, the directed type D x y has a “direction” from x to y, written as (x)->(y). The Prim datatype looks pretty much like the type actually used in Darcs. The Patch datatype, however, is completely artificial. We will see in the next sections how Darcs really models complex patches.

Directed programming


Two particularly useful directed types used in darcs are directed lists: forwards lists of the type FL a x y and reverse lists RL a x y. Forward lists “go” from the head to the tail; reverse lists “go” from the tail to the head. The lists are polymorphic over a just like regular lists.

data FL a x y where
    NilFL :: FL a x x    {- The empty list stays at (x) -}
    (:>:) :: a x y -> FL a y z -> FL a x z
infixr 5 :>:

For myself, I visualise forward lists like this:

(x) —a—> (y) —b—> (z) ——Nil——> (z)
a :: Patch x y
b :: Patch y z
(a :>: b :>: NilFL) :: FL Patch x z

The reverse lists are “going” from tail to head1

data RL a x y where
    NilRL :: RL a x x
    (:<:) :: RL a x y -> a y z -> RL a x z
infixl 5 :<:

(Mnemonically, the the head is always “greater” than the tail)

The reason I used the word “go” inside quotation marks so far is the following. Reverse lists and forward lists represent the same concept: a sequence of patches (or a sequence of directed things for that matter). They only differ in the associativity of the elements. Forward lists associate to the right, but reverse lists associate to the left.

p = Move "foo" "bar"

-- [[(x) --Nil--> (x) -p-> (y)] -id-> (y)] -p^{-1}-> (x)
example :: RL Patch x x
example = NilRL :<: p :<: Identity :<: inverse p

-- (x) -p-> [(y) -p^{-1}-> (x) --Nil--> (x)]
example2 :: FL Patch x x
example2 = p :>: inverse p :>: NilFL

The right-associated/reverse lists provide easy access to the last element of the sequence; the left-associated/forward lists provide easy access to the first element of the sequence. Therefore, if we view a repository as a directed sequence of patches, right-associated lists are useful for operations that work on the “latest” patches in the repository (such as record/unrecord), and left-associated lists are useful for commands that scan the repository from the beginning (like clone).

We can reassociate the lists easily, and verify that the two representations are isomoprhic:2

reverseRL :: RL a wX wY -> FL a wX wY
reverseRL = r NilFL
-- the type signature of r basically gives us an invariant
-- wZ is slowly "decreasing" reaching the point where
-- wZ = wX; at that point the first argument is of type FL a wX wY
  where r :: FL a wZ wY -> RL a wX wZ -> FL a wX wY
        r a NilRL = a
        r a (xs :<: x) = r (x :>: a) xs

For example,

-- [[(x) --Nil--> (x) -p-> (y1)] -q-> (y2)] -r-> (z)

Turns into

-- (x) -p-> [(y1) -q-> (y2) -r-> [(z) --Nil--> (z)]]

Exercise: write a function reverseFL :: FL a wX wY -> RL a wX wY

We can write a lot of directed analogues of familiar list functions. For example, here is a directed append:

infixl 5 +<+
(+<+) :: RL a wX wY -> RL a wY wZ -> RL a wX wZ
xs +<+ NilRL = xs
xs +<+ (ys :<: y) = (xs +<+ ys) :<: y

Exercise: write directed append for forward lists: (+>+) :: FL a wX wY -> FL a wY wZ -> FL a wX wZ

Type witnesses

So we wrote a bunch of standard list functions for directed lists; what about some of the other functions? Can we, for example, implement filter for directed lists. Can it look like filterFL :: (a wX wY -> Bool) -> FL a wX wY? Well, we can try writing

filterFL :: (a wX wY -> Bool) -> FL a wX wY
filterFL p NilFL = NilFL
filterFL p (x :>: xs) | p x = filterFL p xs
                      | otherwise = x :>: filterFL p xs

However, under closer scrutiny we realize that it does not typecheck! In the second clause of filterFL we have the following information:

x :: a x y, xs :: FL a y z
filterFL xs :: FL a y z

Thus, in the first case (in which p x holds) we try to return something of the type FL a wY wZ, when FL a wX wZ was expected. It is clear that generally we can do this only if x :: a wX wX, i.e. wY = wX. But a simple predicate of the type p :: a wX wZ -> Bool won’t tell us anything about that. We need an additional type witness in our system telling us that if p x holds, then x :: a wX wX. For that purpose we introdue the EqCheck datatype.

data EqCheck wX wY where
    IsEq :: EqCheck wX wX
    NotEq :: EqCheck wX wY

then the type of a predicate would be

type Pred a = forall wX wY. a wX wY -> EqCheck wX wY

If (p x) = IsEq, then the typechecker will know that x :: a wX wX. We can then finally write

filterFL :: Pred a -> FL a wX wY -> FL a wX wY
filterFL p NilFL = NilFL
filterFL p (x :>: xs) | IsEq <- p x = filterFL p xs
                      | otherwise   = x :>: filterFL p xs

EqCheck is used this way in the darcs source code to e.g., filter our internal patches. Sometimes darcs stores information — like suspended patches — in the so called internal patches. Every patch type implements the internal patch checker (code slightly adapted):

-- |Provides a hook for flagging whether a patch is "internal" to the repo
-- and therefore shouldn't be referred to externally, e.g. by inclusion in tags.
-- Note that despite the name, every patch type has to implement it, but for
-- normal (non-internal) types the default implementation is fine.
-- Currently only used for rebase internal patches.
class MaybeInternal p where
    -- | @maybe (const NotEq) (fmap isInternal patchInternalChecker) p@
    -- returns 'IsEq' if @p@ is internal, and 'NotEq' otherwise.
    -- The two-level structure is purely for efficiency: 'Nothing' and 'Just (InternalChecker (const NotEq))' are
    -- semantically identical, but 'Nothing' allows clients to avoid traversing an entire list.
    -- The patch type is passed as an 'FL' because that's how the internals of named patches are stored.
    patchInternalChecker :: Maybe (forall wX wY . FL p wX wY -> EqCheck wX wY)
    patchInternalChecker = Nothing

When the user runs darcs tag in the repository, darcs creates a dummy patch that explicitly depends on all the previous patches — apart from the internal ones of course. Thus, the tag command uses the following function (slightly adapted):

filterNonInternal :: MaybeInternal p => PatchSet p wX wY -> PatchSet p wX wY
filterNonInternal =
  case patchInternalChecker of
     Nothing -> id
     Just f -> \l -> PatchSet (filterRL (f . patchcontents . hopefully) (unPatchSet l))

where a PatchSet is the list of PatchInfoAnd patches — patches together with the meta-information.

It is worth noting that EqCheck x y is isomorphic Maybe (x :~: y), but the propositional equality datatype has only been added to base since In the future versions darcs will probably switch to using Data.Type.Equality.


We’ve briefly touched upon patch representation in darcs and talked about directed types and directed programming.

A good if a bit outdated reference is Jason Dagit’s master thesis (specifically the bits from chapter 4). The wiki is currently lacking in material, but I hope to improve the situation eventually.

Next time we will probably discuss either directed pairs and their use in darcs, or sealed datatypes, or both.

  1. Essentially, a reverse list is a directed version of a snoc-list.↩

  2. Before darcs 2.10.1 the right-associated lists had a slightly different datatype, and for the old lists those functions would “reverse” the list. Hence the names of the functions.↩

September 01, 2015

Darcs News

Darcs News #111

September 01, 2015 10:26 PM UTC

News and discussions

  1. The next Darcs Sprint will take place in Paris on September 18-20th. Please add yourself to the wiki page if you're going!
  2. Darcs 2.10.1 has been released (bugfixes, dependency versions bump):

Issues resolved (19)

issue2102 Guillaume Hoffmann
issue2307 Daniil Frumin
issue2308 Ben Franksen
issue2327 Alain91
issue2420 Ben Franksen
issue2421 Guillaume Hoffmann
issue2423 Alain91
issue2433 Guillaume Hoffmann
issue2438 Guillaume Hoffmann
issue2444 Ben Franksen
issue2446 Guillaume Hoffmann
issue2447 Ben Franksen
issue2448 Gian Piero Carrubba
issue2449 Ganesh Sittampalam
issue2451 Ben Franksen
issue2457 Ben Franksen
issue2461 Ben Franksen
issue2461 Ben Franksen
issue2463 Joachim Breitner

Patches applied (145)

See darcs wiki entry for details.

July 28, 2015

Dan Frumin

Darcs rebase by example

July 28, 2015 10:40 AM UTC

Darcs is a patch-centric version control system. In Darcs, there is no “correct” linear history of a repository – rather, there is a poset of patches. That means that most of the time you are pushing and pulling changes you can cherry-pick patches without a problem. However, in some cases you cannot perform a pull (or some other operation on the repository) smoothly. Sometimes it is necessary to rewrite the “history” – i.e. modify a patch that is a dependency of one or more other patches. For those cases darcs rebase comes in handy. To put it in the words of the implementor “Rebase is a workaround for cases where commutation doesn’t do enough”.

A repository can change it’s state from rebase-in-progress back to normal if there are no suspended patches left. However, be aware that you cannot unsuspend a patch1 if you have unrecorded changes in the repository. In light of this, I suggest recording a temporary patch with current changes

darcs record -am DRAFT

You can suspend that patch at the beginning of your rebase process and apply it at the end.

General overview of rebase

darcs rebase is an operation (or, rather, a family of operations) that allows one to make changes “deep down” in the repository history. One of the crucial things that allows for rebase to work is the fact that since darcs 2.10 patches can be suspended. When one performs any of the darcs rebase commands, the repository moves to a special rebase-in-progress state. In this state repository contains a pristine, a set of patches, a working copy, and — in addition to all the usual stuff — a set of suspended patches. Suspended patches are not active in the repository — that is, they are not applied.

Let’s go over the rebase subcommands

rebase log/rebase changes

This is simple: list the suspended patches

rebase suspend

Moves selected patches into the suspended state. Once the patch is suspended it is no longer active in the repository.

Note: once you suspend a patch, it changes its identity. That means that even if you suspend a patch and unsuspend it immediately, you will get a different repository that you have started with. Let this be a good reason (one of a couple!) for doing rebase on a separate branch.

> cat file
> darcs rebase suspend
	patch 64523bc4622fad02a4bdb9261887628b7997ebdd
Author: Daniil Frumin 
Date:   Thu Jul 23 18:49:30 MSK 2015
  * 123
Shall I suspend this patch? (1/5)  [ynW…], or ? for more options: y
patch cc54d7cf4b9e3d13a24ce0b1b77b76581d98d75d
Author: Daniil Frumin 
Date:   Thu Jul 23 18:43:53 MSK 2015
  * Test
Shall I suspend this patch? (2/5)  [ynW…], or ? for more options: d
Rebase in progress: 1 suspended patches
> darcs rebase log
patch 64523bc4622fad02a4bdb9261887628b7997ebdd
Author: Daniil Frumin 
Date:   Thu Jul 23 18:49:30 MSK 2015
  * 123
Shall I view this patch? (1/?) [yN…], or ? for more options: y
Daniil Frumin **20150723154930
 Ignore-this: 43e09e6503ac74688e74441dc29bce25
] hunk ./file 2
Rebase in progress: 1 suspended patches
> cat file

rebase unsuspend

Does the opposite of suspend: applies a suspended patch to the repository and changes its state to normal.

> darcs rebase unsuspend                                                                                       
patch 64523bc4622fad02a4bdb9261887628b7997ebdd
Author: Daniil Frumin 
Date:   Thu Jul 23 18:49:30 MSK 2015
  * 123
Shall I unsuspend this patch? (1/1)  [ynW…], or ? for more options: y
Do you want to unsuspend these patches? [Yglqk…], or ? for more options: y
Rebase finished!

rebase apply

Rebase apply takes a patch bundle and tries to apply all the patches in the bundle to the current repository. If a patch from the bundle conflicts with a local patch, then the local patch gets suspended. You will thus have a chance to resolve the conflict by amending your conflicting patches, at a price of.. well, changing the identity of your local patches.

rebase pull

Sort of like rebase apply, but instead of a patch bundle it obtains the patches from a remote repository.

Specifically, rebase pull applies all the remote patches, one-by-one, suspending any local patches that conflict. We will see more of rebase pull in the second example.

Example 1: suspending local changes

Imagine the following situation: at point A you add a configuration file to your repository, then you record a patch B that updates the settings in the configuration file. After that you make some more records before you realize that you’ve included by accident your private password in patch A! You want to get rid of it in your entire history, but you can’t just unrecord A, because B depends on A, and possibly some other patches depend on B.

The contents of the configuration file after patch A:

port = 6667
host =
password = awesomevcs 

Patch B, diff:

@@ -1,3 +1,4 @@
-port = 6667
+port = 6697
+usessl = True
host =
password = awesomevcs

You cannot just amend patch A, because the patch B depends on A:

> darcs amend                                                                                                         
patch 1925d640f1f3180cb5b9e64260c1b5f374fce4ca
Author: Daniil Frumin 
Date:   Tue Jul 21 13:23:07 MSK 2015
  * B

Shall I amend this patch? [yNjk…], or ? for more options: n

Skipping depended-upon patch:
patch 22d7c8da83141f8b1f80bdd3eff02064d4f45c6b
Author: Daniil Frumin 
Date:   Tue Jul 21 13:22:24 MSK 2015
  * A

Cancelling amend since no patch was selected.

What we will have to do is temporarily suspend patch B, amend patch A, and then unsuspend B.

> darcs rebase suspend
patch 1925d640f1f3180cb5b9e64260c1b5f374fce4ca
Author: Daniil Frumin 
Date:   Tue Jul 21 13:23:07 MSK 2015
  * B

Shall I suspend this patch? (1/2)  [ynW…], or ? for more options: y
patch 22d7c8da83141f8b1f80bdd3eff02064d4f45c6b
Author: Daniil Frumin 
Date:   Tue Jul 21 13:22:24 MSK 2015
  * A

Shall I suspend this patch? (2/2)  [ynW…], or ? for more options: d
Rebase in progress: 1 suspended patches

At this point, the state of our repository is the following: there is one (active) patch A, and one suspended patch B.

> darcs rebase changes -a
patch 4c5d45230dc146932b21964aea938e2a978523eb
Author: Daniil Frumin 
Date:   Tue Jul 21 13:28:58 MSK 2015
  * B

Rebase in progress: 1 suspended patches
> darcs changes -a
patch 21f56dfb425e4c49787bae5db4f8869e96787fb2
Author: Daniil Frumin 
Date:   Tue Jul 21 13:28:49 MSK 2015
  * A

Rebase in progress: 1 suspended patches
> cat config
port = 6667
host =
password = awesomevcs
> $EDITOR config # remove the password bit
> darcs amend
patch 22d7c8da83141f8b1f80bdd3eff02064d4f45c6b
Author: Daniil Frumin 
Date:   Tue Jul 21 13:22:24 MSK 2015
  * A

Shall I amend this patch? [yNjk…], or ? for more options: y
hunk ./config 3
-password = awesomevcs
Shall I record this change? (1/1)  [ynW…], or ? for more options: y
Do you want to record these changes? [Yglqk…], or ? for more options: y
Finished amending patch:
patch 21f56dfb425e4c49787bae5db4f8869e96787fb2
Author: Daniil Frumin 
Date:   Tue Jul 21 13:28:49 MSK 2015
  * A

Rebase in progress: 1 suspended patches

Now that we’ve removed the password from the history, we can safely unsuspend patch B (in this particular situation we actually know that applying B to the current state of the repository won’t be a problem, because B does not conflict with our modified A)

> darcs rebase unsuspend
patch 1925d640f1f3180cb5b9e64260c1b5f374fce4ca
Author: Daniil Frumin 
Date:   Tue Jul 21 13:23:07 MSK 2015
  * B

Shall I unsuspend this patch? (1/1)  [ynW…], or ? for more  options: y
Do you want to unsuspend these patches? [Yglqk…], or ? for more options: y
Rebase finished!

And that’s done!

> cat config
port = 6697
usessl = True
host =

You may use this rebase strategy for removing sensitive information from the repository, for removing that 1GB binary .iso that you added to your repository by accident, or for combining two patches into one deep down in the patchset.

Example 2: developing against a changing upstream – rebase pull

Imagine you have a fork R’ of a repository R that you are working on. You are implementing a feature that involves a couple of commits. During your work you record a commit L1 that refractors some common datum from modules A.hs and B.hs. You proceed with your work recording a patch L2. At this point you realise that after you forked R, the upstream recorded two more patches U1 and U2, messing with the common datum in A.hs. If you just pull U1 into your fork R’, you will have a conflict, that you will have to resolve by recording another patch on top.

     / \
    /   \
   L1   U1

Note: if you run darcs rebase pull in R’, then the only patches that will be suspended are the ones which are already in R’. Because suspended patches gain new identity, make sure that you do not have other people’s conflicting patches present in R’.

The way to solve this would be to first do darcs rebase pull, which would suspend the conflicting patches, and then start unsuspending the patches one by one, making sure that you fix any conflicts that may arise after each unsuspend.

Consider a concrete example with two repositories rep1 and rep1_0.

rep1_0 > darcs changes 
patch ebaccd5c36667b7e3ee6a49d25ef262f0c7edf2b
Author: Daniil Frumin 
Date:   Mon Jul 27 20:56:25 MSK 2015
  * commit2

patch a7e0d92a53b0523d0224ef8ffae4362adf854485
Author: Daniil Frumin 
Date:   Mon Jul 27 20:56:25 MSK 2015
  * commit1
	rep1_0 > darcs diff —from-patch=commit2
patch ebaccd5c36667b7e3ee6a49d25ef262f0c7edf2b
Author: Daniil Frumin 
Date:   Mon Jul 27 20:56:25 MSK 2015
  * commit2
diff -rN -u old-rep1_0/dir1/file2 new-rep1_0/dir1/file2
— old-rep1_0/dir1/file2	1970-01-01 03:00:00.000000000 +0300
    +++ new-rep1_0/dir1/file2	2015-07-28 12:25:54.000000000 +0300
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+double whatsup
	rep1_0 > cd ../rep1
rep1 > darcs changes
patch e3df0e23a3915910a81eb8181d7b3669e8f270a9
Author: Daniil Frumin 
Date:   Tue Jul 28 12:27:55 MSK 2015
  * commit2’

patch a7e0d92a53b0523d0224ef8ffae4362adf854485
Author: Daniil Frumin 
Date:   Mon Jul 27 20:56:25 MSK 2015
  * commit1
rep1 > darcs diff —from-patch=“commit2’”
patch e3df0e23a3915910a81eb8181d7b3669e8f270a9
Author: Daniil Frumin 
Date:   Tue Jul 28 12:27:55 MSK 2015
  * commit2’
diff -rN -u old-rep1/dir1/file2 new-rep1/dir1/file2
— old-rep1/dir1/file2	1970-01-01 03:00:00.000000000 +0300
+++ new-rep1/dir1/file2	2015-07-28 12:28:39.000000000 +0300
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+touch file2
\ No newline at end of file
diff -rN -u old-rep1/file1 new-rep1/file1 — old-rep1/file1	2015-07-28 12:28:39.000000000 +0300 +++ new-rep1/file1	2015-07-28 12:28:39.000000000 +0300
@@ -1 +1 @@
\ No newline at end of file
+double whatsup
\ No newline at end of file

The patch commit2 from rep1_0 conflicts with commit2’ from rep1.

rep1 > darcs rebase pull ../rep1_0
patch ebaccd5c36667b7e3ee6a49d25ef262f0c7edf2b
Author: Daniil Frumin 
Date:   Mon Jul 27 20:56:25 MSK 2015
  * commit2
Shall I pull this patch? (1/1)  [ynW…], or ? for more options: y
Do you want to pull these patches? [Yglqk…], or ? for more options: y
The following local patches are in conflict:
patch e3df0e23a3915910a81eb8181d7b3669e8f270a9
Author: Daniil Frumin 
Date:   Tue Jul 28 12:27:55 MSK 2015
  * commit2’
Shall I suspend this patch? (1/1)  [ynW…], or ? for more options: y
Do you want to suspend these patches? [Yglqk…], or ? for more options: y
Finished pulling.
Rebase in progress: 1 suspended patches

Now we have one patch — commit2’ — in the suspended state. We want to resolve the conflict by amending commit2’. We will do that by unsuspending it and manually editing out the conflicting lines. This will also make it depend on commit2.

rep1 > darcs rebase unsuspend
patch e3df0e23a3915910a81eb8181d7b3669e8f270a9
Author: Daniil Frumin 
Date:   Tue Jul 28 12:27:55 MSK 2015
  * commit2’
Shall I unsuspend this patch? (1/1)  [ynW…], or ? for more options: y
Do you want to unsuspend these patches? [Yglqk…], or ? for more options: d
We have conflicts in the following files:

Rebase finished!
rep1 > cat dir1/file2
v v v v v v v

double whatsup
touch file2
^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^
rep1 > $EDITOR dir1/file2
rep1 > darcs amend -a
patch 40b3b4123c78dba6a6797feb619572072654a9cd
Author: Daniil Frumin 
Date:   Tue Jul 28 12:32:56 MSK 2015
  * commit2’
Shall I amend this patch? [yNjk…], or ? for more options: y
Finished amending patch:
patch c35867259f187c1bc30310f1cacb34c1bb2cce41
Author: Daniil Frumin 
Date:   Tue Jul 28 12:34:30 MSK 2015
  * commit2’
rep1 > darcs mark-conflicts
No conflicts to mark.

Another repository saved from conflicting patches, yay!

  1. See this discussion for details↩

July 12, 2015

Dan Frumin

Darcs 2.10.1 (Mac OSX build)

July 12, 2015 06:13 PM UTC

Darcs 2.10.1 has been released!

Citing the official release notes

> The darcs team is pleased to announce the release of darcs 2.10.1 !
> ..
> # What's new in 2.10.1 (since 2.10.0) #
> - generalized doFastZip for darcsden support
> - support terminfo 0.4, network 2.6, zlib 0.6, quickcheck 2.8 and
> attoparsec 0.13
> - errorDoc now prints a stack trace (if profiling was enabled) (Ben Franksen)
> - beautified error messages for command line and default files (Ben Franksen)
> - fixed the following bugs:
>       - issue2449: test harness/shelly: need to handle
> mis-encoded/binary data (Ganesh Sittampalam)
>       - issue2423: diff only respecting --diff-command when a diff.exe
> is present (Alain91)
>       - issue2447: get contents of deleted file (Ben Franksen)
>       - issue2307: add information about 'darcs help manpage' and
> 'darcs help markdown' (Dan Frumin)
>       - issue2461: darcs log --repo=remoterepo creates and populates
> _darcs (Ben Franksen)
>       - issue2459: cloning remote repo fails to use packs if cache is
> on a different partition (Ben Franksen)
> # Feedback #
> If you have an issue with darcs 2.10.0, you can report it on
> . You can also report bugs by email to
> bugs at, or come to #darcs on

I’ve updated Mac OS to version 2.10.1. You can install it with

brew install

July 11, 2015

Dan Frumin

HTTP Basic auth in Snap

July 11, 2015 09:27 AM UTC

Recently, I’ve implemented HTTP Basic auth for darcsden and wrote a simple wreq test for it. In this post I would like to outline the main technical details.

Server side

Transient storage

A lot of darcsden code is (especially the parts that are closer to the users’ web browser — handlers, pages, so on) is written around sessions. Sessions are stored in a special storage — implemented by the DarcsDen.Backend.Transient, but if we abstract away from the details we have a Session datatype. Authorization and authentication information is handled by sessions using functions setUser :: (BTIO bt) => Maybe User -> Session -> Snap Session, notice :: (BTIO bt) => String -> Session -> Snap () (display a message to the user) and others. The BTIO bt part is just a synonym for

type BTIO bt = (BackendTransient bt, ?backendTransient :: bt, MonadIO (BackendTransientM bt))

Which basically says that we are operating with a transient backend that supports all of necessary operations, and we can also do IO in it. Right now there are only two transient backends (read: two ways of storing sessions): Redis and in-process memory.

Running sessions

If we have a piece of Snap code that we want to “sessionify” we use the following interface:

withSession :: (BTIO bt) => (Session -> Snap ()) -> Snap ()

What this does is it basically checks for a cookie — in case it is present it grabs the session information from the storage (in accordance with the cookie); if the cookie is not present it creates a new session and stores it in a cookie.

If we have a page of a type Session -> Snap (), we might want to give user an option to do HTTP authentication on that page. We introduce another function

withBasicAuth :: (BP bp, BTIO bt) 
              => (Session -> Snap ()) 
              -> (Session -> Snap ())
withBasicAuth act s = do
    rq  do
          rawHeader <- maybe throwChallenge return $ getHeader “Authorization” rq
          let (Just (usr,pw)) = getCredentials rawHeader
          c  errorPage “Unknown user”
            Just u -> if checkPassword (fromBS pw) u
                         then doLogin (fromBS usr)
                         else errorPage “Bad password”
      _ -> act s

So, what is going on in here? First of all, we check if the “login” parameter is set to “true”. If it does, we try to get the “Authorization” header, de-encode it, and check whether the credentials are good.

throwChallenge :: Snap a
throwChallenge = do
    modifyResponse $ (setResponseStatus 401 “Unauthorized”) .
                     (setHeader “WWW-Authenticate” “Basic realm=darcsdenrealm”)
    getResponse >>= finishWith

If the response header is present, it is of a form Basic x, where x is a base64 encoded string user:password. We can extract the credentials from the header like this:

import qualified Data.ByteString          as B
import qualified Data.ByteString.Base64   as B
getCredentials :: B.ByteString  — ^ Header
               -> Maybe (B.ByteString, B.ByteString) — ^ Possibly (username, password)
getCredentials header =
    if (isInfixOf “Basic “ header)
      then fmap extract (hush (B.decode (B.drop 6 header)))
      else Nothing
    extract cred = case (B.breakByte (c2w ‘:’) cred) of
                     (usr, pw) -> (usr, safeTail pw)

On the client

The tests that I am currently writing for darcsden are all of the same form: I use wreq to do requests to the darcsden server, then, if necessary, I run taggy to extract information from the webpage, and compare it to the “canonical” information.

As it turns out, doing HTTP Basic Auth is very easy with wreq! First of all, we define a function for doing a GET request that will do some exception handling for us:

getSafeOpts :: Options -> String -> IO (Either Status (Response ByteString))
getSafeOpts opts url = fmap Right (getWith opts url) `catch` hndlr
    hndlr (StatusCodeException s _ _) = return (Left s)
    hndlr e = throwIO e

This way, we won’t get a runtime exception when accessing a non-existing page or getting a server error. Doing a GET request with HTTP Basic Auth is now very easy:

getWithAuth :: (String, String) -> String -> IO (Either Status (Response ByteString))
getWithAuth (username,pw) url = getSafeOpts opts url
    opts = defaults & auth ?~ basicAuth (toBS username) (toBS pw)
                    & param “login” .~ [“true”]

In that snippet we use lenses to set up an auth header and an HTTP parameter (?login=true).

Finally, after obtaining a Response ByteString, we can parse it with taggy-lens:

parsed :: Fold (Response L.ByteString) Text.Taggy.Node
parsed = responseBody 
       . to (decodeUtf8With lenientDecode)
       . html

We can then play with it in GHCi

*Main> Right r  r ^.. parsed
[NodeElement (Element {eltName = “DOCTYPE”, eltAttrs = fromList [(“html”,””)], eltChildren = [NodeElement (Element {eltName = “html”, eltAttrs = fromList [], eltChildren = [NodeElement (Element {eltName = “head”, eltAttrs = fromList [], eltChildren = [NodeElement (Element {eltName = “title”, eltAttrs = fromList [], eltChildren = [NodeContent “localhost”]}),NodeElement (Element {eltName = “link”, eltAttrs = fromList [(“href”,”http://localhost:8900/public/images/favicon.ico”),…

If we want to check that we are indeed logged in correctly, we should look for the “log out” button. Taggy does all the heavy lifting for us, we just have to write down a lens (more precisely, a fold) to “extract” a logout button from the page

logoutButton :: HasElement e => Fold e Text
logoutButton = allAttributed (ix “class” . only “logout”)
             . allNamed (only “a”)
             . contents

logoutButton searches for <div class=“logout”> and returns the text in the link inside the div. There might be many such links inside the node, hence we use a fold.

*Main> r ^.. parsed . logoutButton
[“log out”]

In this case, since we only care if such link is present, we can use a preview

*Main> r ^? parsed . logoutButton
Just “log out”


Well, that’s about it for now. I regret taking way too much time writing this update, and I hope to deliver another one soon. Meanwhile, some information regarding the darcsden SoC project can be found on the wiki.

July 09, 2015

Darcs News

darcs 2.10.1 release

July 09, 2015 05:10 PM UTC

Hi all,

The darcs team is pleased to announce the release of darcs 2.10.1 !


The easiest way to install darcs 2.10.1 from source is by first installing the Haskell Platform ( If you have installed the Haskell Platform or cabal-install, you can install this release by doing:

$ cabal update
$ cabal install darcs-2.10.1

Alternatively, you can download the tarball from and build it by hand as explained in the README file.

The 2.10 branch is also available as a darcs repository from

What's new in darcs 2.10.1 (since darcs 2.10.0)


If you have an issue with darcs 2.10.1, you can report it on . You can also report bugs by email to, or come to #darcs on

June 22, 2015

Dan Frumin

Darcs binaries for OSX with Homebrew

June 22, 2015 12:33 PM UTC

Recently I’ve updated my Darcs homebrew build to Darcs 2.10. You can install it with

brew install

The formula contains a context (--exact-version) and it is a static binary.

May 13, 2015

Dan Frumin

Hoogle inside the sandbox

May 13, 2015 09:54 PM UTC


This is my first post from the (hopefuly fruitful!) series of blog posts as part of my Haskell SoC project. I will spend a great chunk of my summer hacking away on DarcsDen; in addition, I will document my hardships and successes here. You can follow my progress on my DarcsHub.

This particular post will be about my working environment.

The problem

Hoogle is an amazing tool that usually needs no introduction. Understandably, the online version at indexes only so many packages. This means that if I want to use hoogle to search for functions and values in packages like darcs and darcsden, I will have to set up a local copy.

Cabal sandboxing is a relatively recent feature of the Cabal package manager, but I don’t think it is reasonable in this day to install from the source (let alone develop) a Haskell package without using sandboxing.

The problem seems to be that the mentioned tools do not play well together out of the box, and some amount of magic is required. In this note I sketch the solution, on which I’ve eventually arrived after a couple of tries.

Using hoogle inside a Cabal sandbox

The presumed setup: a user is working on a package X using the cabal sandboxes. The source code is located in the directory X and the path to the cabal sandbox is X/.cabal-sandbox.

Step 1: Install hoogle inside the sandbox. This is simply a matter of running cabal install hoogle inside X. If you want to have a standard database alongside the database for your packages in development, now is the time to do .cabal-sandbox/bin/hoogle data.

Step 2: Generate haddocks for the packages Y,Z you want to use with hoogle. In my case, I wanted to generate haddocks for darcs and darcsden. This is just a matter of running cabal haddock --hoogle in the correct directory.

Step 3: Convert haddocks to .hoo files. Run the following commands in X/:

.cabal-sandbox/bin/hoogle convert /path/to/packageY/dist/doc/html/*/*.txt

You should see something like

Converting /path/to/packageY/dist/doc/html/Y/Y.txt
Converting Y... done

after which the file Y.hoo appears in /path/to/packageY/dist/doc/html/Y/

Step 4: Moving and combining databases. The hoogle database should be stored in .cabal-sandbox/share/*/hoogle-*/databases. Create such directory, if it’s not present already. Then copy the ‘default’ database to that folder:

cp .cabal-sandbox/hoogle/databases/default.hoo .cabal-sandbox/share/*/hoogle-*/databases

Finally, you can combine your Y.hoo with the default database.

.cabal-sandbox/bin/hoogle combine /path/to/packageY/dist/doc/html/*/*.hoo .cabal-sandbox/share/*/hoogle-*/databases/default.hoo
mv default.hoo .cabal-sandbox/share/*/hoogle-*/databases/default.hoo

And you are done! You can test your installation

$ .cabal-sandbox/bin/hoogle rOwner
DarcsDen.State.Repo rOwner :: Simple Lens (Repository bp) String

For additional usability, consider adding .cabal-sandbox/bin to your $PATH.

April 20, 2015

Simon Michael

ssh, Darcs Hub vulnerability

April 20, 2015 11:10 PM UTC

I recently learned of a serious undocumented vulnerability in the ssh package. This is a minimal ssh server implementation used by darcsden to support darcs push/pull. If you use the ssh package, or you have darcsden’s darcsden-ssh server running, you should upgrade to/rebuild with the imminent ssh-0.3 release right away. Or if you know of someone like that, please let them know.

darcsden is of course the basis for Darcs Hub. Here’s the announcement I sent to users there a few days ago, with more details.

Hello darcs hub users,

This is Simon Michael, operator of, with the first all-darcs-hub-users announcement. You’re receiving this because you have an email address configured in your darcs hub user settings.

Thank you for using darcs hub, and for any feedback/bug reports/patches you may have sent. Usage is growing steadily, and I plan to blog more about it soon at

This email is to announce a recently patched security vulnerability in darcs hub’s SSH server.


3/21: a software developer reports that the haskell “ssh” library used by darcs hub does not check for a valid signature on the public key during authentication. This means it was possible to authenticate as any other ssh user if you knew their public key.

3/21-: I discuss the issue with a small number of core darcs developers and the ssh author.

3/25: A preliminary fix is deployed. We believe this closed the vulnerability.

4/6: A more comprehensive and tested fix is deployed.

4/15: This announcement is sent to current darcs hub users with valid email addresses (714 of 765 users).

4/20: Public disclosure via blog, haskell mail lists and the issue tracker (darcsden #130).

Impact and current status:

We believe the vulnerability is now fixed. But we are not cryptographers - I’m sure the new ssh maintainer would welcome any help from some of those.

We have no reason to believe anyone discovered or exploited the vulnerability. Also, it seems unlikely there’s anything hosted on darcs hub that would attract this kind of attention. darcs hub logs are not good enough to be certain, however. It’s possible I’ll find a way to be more certain by looking at file timestamps or something.

The weakness was present in darcs hub’s ssh server since it went live (and in before that). As mentioned, it was possible to authenticate via ssh as another user if you provided their public ssh key. With ssh access, it’s possible to create, delete, modify or replace any repository in that darcs hub account (but not possible to change user settings in the web app, or to access the system hosting darcshub).

The worst-case scenario we’ve imagined is that a motivated attacker could have authenticated as you and replaced your repo with one that looks just like it, but with patches altered or added, any time since you created the repo on darcs hub (or on, if you moved it from there).

So if you’re paranoid/careful you may want to check the integrity of your repos, eg by reviewing the repo history (“changes” button on the website, “darcs log [-s] [-v]” at the console). If you have more questions about this, you can contact me ( and if necessary Ganesh Sittampalam ( privately.

Future plans:


Some logistical things to be aware of:

Needless to say, I regret the vulnerability and am pleased to have it closed. Of course we are not alone, eg github had their own incident. Thank you very much to all who have been helping with this, especially the original reporter for letting us all know, and Ganesh for providing swift and high quality fixes.

April 19, 2015

Darcs News

darcs 2.10.0 release

April 19, 2015 10:01 PM UTC

Hi all,

The darcs team is pleased to announce the release of darcs 2.10.0.


The easiest way to install darcs 2.10.0 from source is by first installing the Haskell Platform ( If you have installed the Haskell Platform or cabal-install, you can install this release by doing:

$ cabal update
$ cabal install darcs-2.10.0

Alternatively, you can download the tarball from and build it by hand as explained in the README file.

The 2.10 branch is also available as a darcs repository from


If you have an issue with darcs 2.10.0, you can report it via the web on . You can also report bugs by email to bugs at, or come to #darcs on

What's new since darcs 2.8.5

New features

User Interface


Issues resolved in Darcs 2.10

Known issues

These are known new issues in darcs 2.10.0:

March 04, 2015

Darcs News

Darcs News #110

March 04, 2015 12:18 PM UTC

News and discussions

  1. The Darcs 2.10 release is near! Please test the release branch and tell us if you find a bug.
  2. Joachim Breitner has shut down his darcswatch service after 7 years of activity:

Issues resolved (11)

issue822 Ernesto Rodriguez
issue2260 Ganesh Sittampalam
issue2385 Guillaume Hoffmann
issue2410 Guillaume Hoffmann
issue2411 Guillaume Hoffmann
issue2414 Guillaume Hoffmann
issue2418 Guillaume Hoffmann
issue2422 Ganesh Sittampalam
issue2427 Ben Franksen
issue2431 Ben Franksen
issue2432 Ganesh Sittampalam
issue2437 Guillaume Hoffmann

Patches applied (111)

See darcs wiki entry for details.

November 18, 2014

Darcs News

Darcs News #107

November 18, 2014 03:45 AM UTC

News and discussions

  1. Darcs has received two grants from the Google Summer of Code program, as part of the umbrella organization Alejandro Gadea will work on history reordering:
  2. Marcio Diaz will work on the cache system:
  3. Repository cloning to remote ssh hosts has been present for years as darcs put. This feature has now a more efficient implementation:

Issues resolved (11)

issue851 Dan Frumin
issue1066 Guillaume Hoffmann
issue1268 Guillaume Hoffmann
issue1416 Ale Gadea
issue1987 Marcio Diaz
issue2263 Ale Gadea
issue2345 Dan Frumin
issue2357 Dan Frumin
issue2365 Guillaume Hoffmann
issue2367 Guillaume Hoffmann
issue2379 Guillaume Hoffmann

Patches applied (41)

See darcs wiki entry for details.

Darcs News #109

November 18, 2014 03:45 AM UTC

News and discussions

  1. We are in the feature freeze period of darcs 2.10:
  1. Our two Summer of Code projects ended up two months ago. Marcio and Ale's code will be part of the upcoming new stable version of darcs. In case you missed them, here are the latest posts of Marcio for his project:
  1. Ale's posts:

Issues resolved (7)

issue1514 Guillaume Hoffmann
issue1624 Marcio Diaz
issue2153 Andreas Brandt
issue2249 Mateusz Lenik
issue2380 Owen Stephens
issue2403 Ganesh Sittampalam
issue2409 Ganesh Sittampalam

Patches applied (118)

See darcs wiki entry for details.

August 19, 2014

Ale Gadea

Last Few Weeks

August 19, 2014 05:44 AM UTC

In the last three weeks I was working in a couple of things, unfortunately I couldn't complete any to 100% :

- Finishing the command minimize-context.
- Implement the "show dependencies" for darcsden.
- Solve the issue2405.

Finish the command minimize-context

I can start telling that the command itself is implemented, but making tests I find out a case when making minimize-context fails to update correctly the files of repository. I comment the problem in here, however here goes a little summary.

Some "preconditions" to take into account:
1. If exist a tag, I search for dependencies in the patchs after the tag.
2. If happends that not exist dependencies after the tag, the only patch in the context of the bundle to send is the tag. This helps the command darcs apply to merge the patches and seems good to have at least a "tag patch" dependency.
3. (In relation with 1) If not exist a tag, the search is made in all the repository. One problem here is that with repositories that have huge amount of patches (darcs for example with 11000~ patches) the command maybe not finish of calculate the dependencies. Hopefully, having so many patches without tags seems a little odd. Nevertheless, I suppose that even the search in 700~ patches of 10~ patches to send should have a decent performance.

Well, passing to comment the problem. In some older post I mention the way we calculate the dependencies, so with that in mind, suppose we have to repositories $r_1$, $r_2$ with the following patches, where $m_x$ and $a_x$ represents the $x$-th modification and adding respectively.

$r_1$,$r_2$ = $m_2$ $tag$ $m_1$ $a_1$

suppose now that $r_2$ makes a third modification $m_3$ that adds lines without touch any existing line in the only file adding for $a_1$ and sequentially modified for $m_x$. With the idea of send a bundle to $r_1$. Now if we compute the dependencies to find out what is the context to send. For (1) we need to try to commute $m_2$ with $m_3$, which success but of course the end result is a $m'_3$ and a $m'_2$ because the lines which modifies every one now are different. But beyond that for our definition of dependency we can throw $m_2$, so the final context of the bundle with minimize context is the patch $tag$.

The problem now is that if we make darcs apply of the minimized bundle the merge is made not considering $m_2$ and the final state of the file isn't right. For example, if we are talking about that $m_3$ adds a function in some empty place, this could end in $m_3$ adding the function in the middle of an existing function.

My, more or less, mature thought is something like have Direct Dependency and  Indirect Dependency (the names could be differents $\smile$). The Direct Dependency is a dependency as already we know it and the Indirect Dependency is that if we have,

$p_1$ and $p_2$ patches, and $p'_1$ and $p'_2$  are the results of commute the patches, then if $p_1 \ne p'_1$ we conclude that $p_1$ indirectly depends of $p_2$.

I have almost implemented this idea, but I change task and still missing a couple of details. In particular, I'm not so sure of a couple of things,

- How to correctly compare the patches ($p_1 \ne p'_1$)
- In my unclean implementation I have to carry on $MyEq$ for all over the code and it's very ugly I think.

Finishing with this topic, here is a script (improved by Guillaume) that shows the problem:

Implement the "show dependencies" for darcsden

An idea that quickly comes up to my mind is that, considering the last part of the previous topic, since we have two types of dependencies it would be nice generate the graph of dependencies with two types of arrows to differentiate the type of dependency between patches. Talking about the implementation itself, I advanced in the drawing of the graph and some different presentations, but very little about the integration with darcsden, which I think is more or less direct having implemented the $js$ that draw the graph. Would have been nice have more time for finish this but I swap to the task of the following topic.

I hope be able to work in the last two topics in the next few months outside of the GSoC.

Solve the issue2405

I would like to start saying, "what a shame...". I can't solve the issue, I improve a little bit the memory but nothing too much significant. Maybe the good news is that, more o less, I found the "place" in the code where the memory triggers "to the sky" :)

Now, the reality is that I tried so many things that I'm a little bit confused about everything. So, I gonna comment the last feelings and tests that I make and, any question(or idea) for the future person (maybe me) that would try to solve the issue, it would well received.

So things that I tried to change:

- Strict version of Map, Monad, etc.
- More strict version of mapM_, gets and modify.
- Some partials changes in the data type PatchIndex.
- Using darcs as library; differents uses of the functions...

The "place" that I suspect the code has the memory glitch is in $applyPatchMods \rightarrow go (pid, PTouch fn)$I think that my lack of experience dealing with this kind of problem comes to light :) the
bright side is that I learn many things on the way of understand the problem and try different solutions.

Closing, maybe this could be my last post in a long time. I would like to thanks Guillaume and the darcs community in general. It was great to contribute to the development of darcs!

Again, I hope be able to work a little outside the GSoC, in particular in the "dependency problems and tasks".


August 01, 2014

Ale Gadea

Other Week (21-26 July)

August 01, 2014 07:13 AM UTC

Good news!

I almost finish to implement the option minimize-context for the command darcs send, I say almost because making some examples I find out that somethings could go wrong. But before entering in that, I will comment a little the main the test that without minimize-context doesn't work and with the option passes(when the implementation is ready the most likely is I will upload the example and some more in ExamplesRepos), and some "tentatives options" for darcs send that I think could be useful.

So, the minimal example:

Suppose we have repositories $r_1$, $r_2$ and $r_3$; $r_2$ a direct clone of $r_1$ where
originally $r_1$ has only one patch, 

$r_1$,$r_2$ $=$ $p_0$

now, we add a patch with a new file in $r_1$ and make a clone, $r_3$ which leave the repositories like this,

$r_1$,$r_3$ $=$ $p_0$ $p_1$

Suppose that we make a modification in the file that add $p_0$ and make a patch $p'_0$ in $r_1$ and we send a bundle (with darcs send) to $r_2$ and $r_3$. What ends up happening is what one imagine,
the bundle can be applied to $r_3$ but not to $r_2$, this because the bundle has de following "shape":

Some message

patch [Some hash]
Author: ...
Date: ...
  * [The modification to $p_0$]

New patches:




Patch bundle hash: [Some hash]

and $r_2$ doesn't have the patch $p_1$ despite the fact that $p_1$ nothing has to do with $p'_0$. Using the option minimize-context the bundle is the same but the "Context" is:



and now there is no problem.

Now, I find out that reducing the context is not always the "best option" for send a bundle. Here I will expose something that could go wrong. Take for example the darcs-screened repository, in total has 11000~ patches, suppose we add a file and make a bundle (using minimize-context) with only the patch that make the add, the context then is empty. So, if we try to apply this bundle to, say the remote repository, this could never end...
What go wrong?; because the context is empty, making darcs apply [TheBundle] in some point try to merge the entire repository versus the "set" of patches to apply, this is very costly if we have 11000~ patches.

I write "best option" before because with my current solution is not always is better reduce the context, but the final idea is that always be the best option. So, I think is necessary to have some care for example in the last implementation if exist a tag, this tag is added to the context. This simple solution solves the problem and seems correct, on the other hand having more than 600~ or 1000~ patches without a tag seem a little extreme :)

Ending, I'm making some tests of two interesting options that came to mind:

. --last-deps=NUMBER
. --deps-from-tag=REGEXP

The first searches dependencies in the first N patches, and the second search since a given tag.

In conclusion, I'm still doubtful about how solve that problem. More if I have consider the two options. For the end of the week I hope have all this solved.

July 24, 2014

Ale Gadea

Some Week (14-19 July)

July 24, 2014 04:43 AM UTC

Hi all!

I was finishing understanding and implementing the command darcs send --minimize-context using "optimize reorder" when I begin to suspect that doesn't solve the problem described in here. The thing is, despite the fact that the context in the bundle to send is reduced if before we send we make "optimize reorder", this doesn't solve the problem of dependencies. Guillaume finished of evacuate my doubts, and so after read:

[darcs-users] darcs cannot apply some patch bundles
issue1514 (which is the issue which "replace" issue2044 darcs send should do optimize --reorder)

I convince myself of what needs to be done, and it's calculate the "exact" dependencies of the patches to send so such dependencies be the context in the bundle to send. "Exact" because for big repositories can be very costly and calculate till certain tag seem appropriate.

Now, one concern is the cost of doing the search of dependencies. About this I can first comment some of the things I was doing during the week and later show, what I think are, encouraging examples. So first, maybe the most relevant thing of the week it's the implementation of the command darcs show dependencies with the following "description":

Usage: darcs show dependencies [OPTION]... 
Generate the graph of dependencies.

              --from-match=PATTERN  select changes starting with a patch matching PATTERN
              --from-patch=REGEXP   select changes starting with a patch matching REGEXP
              --from-tag=REGEXP     select changes starting with a tag matching REGEXP
              --last=NUMBER         select the last NUMBER patches
              --matches=PATTERN     select patches matching PATTERN
  -p REGEXP   --patches=REGEXP      select patches matching REGEXP
  -t REGEXP   --tags=REGEXP         select tags matching REGEXP
              --disable             disable this command
  -h          --help                shows brief description of command and its arguments

till the moment the command returns a graph described in dot language, this can eventually change. But with the current returned value one can do:

$\$$ darcs show dep | dot -Tpdf -o deps.pdf

to draw the graph in a pdf. Finally, in summary to calculate the dependencies I use more or less the idea which describes Ganesh in here.

Moving to the examples is interesting, thinking in the performance of the implementation of darcs send --minimize-context using this approach, to see the followings results:

1. Show the dependencies after the tag 2.9.9 (75 patches)
$ time darcs show dep --from-tag=2.9.9
real 0m0.397s
user 0m0.373s
sys 0m0.026s

2. Show the dependencies after the tag 2.9.8 (133 patches)
$ time darcs show dep --from-tag=2.9.8
real 0m2.951s
user 0m2.865s
sys 0m0.082s

3. Show the dependencies after the tag 2.9.7 (288 patches)
$ time darcs show dep --from-tag=2.9.7
real 0m26.654s
user 0m26.003s
sys 0m0.511s

4. Show the dependencies after the tag 2.9.6 (358 patches)
$ time darcs show dep --from-tag=2.9.6
real 0m39.019s
user 0m38.302s
sys 0m0.666s

5. Show the dependencies after the tag 2.9.5 (533 patches)
$ time darcs show dep --from-tag=2.9.5
real 1m53.730s
user 1m51.343s
sys 0m1.939s

Rushed conclusion, seems the performance is quite good even more if we think that for compute the graph dependencies we calculate the dependencies of "all the selected patches against all the selected patches" and in the case of the option for send would only require to calculate "patches to send against all the selected patches".

July 15, 2014

Ale Gadea

Month of June

July 15, 2014 01:43 AM UTC

Here goes a little summary of what I been doing between late june (9~21) and early july (1~11).

First and easy, I have been documenting Darcs.misplacedPatches (old name chooseOrder), D.P.W.Ordered and D.P.W.Sealed. Something to comment is that the semantics of misplacedPatches, not always can clean a tag doing darcs optimize reorder. For example; Suppose we have a repository, $r_1$ with the following patches;

$r_1$ $=$ $t_{1,0}$ $p_{1,0}$ $t_{1,1}$

here all tags are clean, but if we make another repository, say $r_2$, and we pull from $r_1$ of the
following way

$\$$ darcs pull -a -p $p_{1,0}$ $r_1$ (we want to pull the patch $p_{1,0}$, we assume that the name of the patch is $p_{1,0}$ for the matching with -p option)
$\$$ darcs pull -a $r_1$

so now we have,

$r_2$ $=$ $p_{1,0}$ $t_{1,0}$ $t_{1,1}$

and we see that $t_{1,0}$ is dirty. Doing darcs optimize reorder not reorder nothing. What is going on is that to know what reorder, misplacePatches takes the first tag, in our case $t_{1,1}$, and
"search" for what patches he don't tag. But $p_{1,0}$ and $t_{1,0}$ are tagged by $t_{1,1}$ so there is nothing to reorder despite $t_{1,0}$ is dirty. Therefore there is no way of clean $t_{1,0}$ because misplacePatches always takes the first tag, so if a tag is tagging one or more dirty tags, this tags never be available to get clean.

"Second", using the implementation of "reorder" one can get almost for free the option --reorder for the commands pull, apply and rebase pull. The behavior for the case of pull (for the others commands is the same basic idea) is that our local patches remain on top after a pull from a remote repository, e.i. suppose we have the followings $l$(ocal) and $r$(emote) repositories,

$l$ $=$ $p_1$ $p_2$ $\ldots$ $p_n$ $lp_{n+1}$ $\ldots$ $lp_m$

$r$ $=$ $p_1$ $p_2$ $\ldots$ $p_n$ $rp_{n+1}$ $\ldots$ $rp_k$

where $lp$ are the local patches that don't belong to $r$, and vice versa for $rp$. Make darcs pull, leaves $l$ as follow,

$l$ $=$ $p_1$ $p_2$ $\ldots$ $p_n$ $lp_{n+1}$ $\ldots$ $lp_m$ $rp_{n+1}$ $\ldots$ $rp_k$

meanwhile make darcs pull --reorder, leaves $l$,

$l$ $=$ $p_1$ $p_2$ $\ldots$ $p_n$ $rp_{n+1}$ $\ldots$ $rp_k$ $lp_{n+1}$ $\ldots$ $lp_m$

making more easy to send the $lp$ patches later.

"Third", beginning a new task, implement option minimize-context for command darcs send. Still no much to comment, I have almost finished implementing the option but with some doubts, I hope that for the end of the week have a more "prettier" implementation as well as a better understanding.

June 25, 2014

Darcs News

darcs news #104

June 25, 2014 04:59 AM UTC

News and discussions

  1. Google Summer of Code 2013 has begun! BSRK and José will post updates on their blogs:

Issues resolved (8)

issue2163 Radoslav Dorcik
issue2227 Ganesh Sittampalam
issue2248 Ganesh Sittampalam
issue2250 BSRK Aditya
issue2311 Sebastian Fischer
issue2312 Sebastian Fischer
issue2320 Jose Luis Neder
issue2321 Jose Luis Neder

Patches applied (20)

See darcs wiki entry for details.

darcs news #105

June 25, 2014 04:58 AM UTC

News and discussions

  1. This year's Google Summer of Code projects brought a lot of improvements to darcs and its ecosystem!
  2. Gian Piero Carrubba asked why adjacent hunks could not commute:
  3. We listed the changes that occurred between version 2.8.4 and the current development branch into a 2.10 release page:

Issues resolved (8)

issue346 Jose Luis Neder
issue1828 Guillaume Hoffmann
issue2181 Guillaume Hoffmann
issue2309 Owen Stephens
issue2313 Jose Luis Neder
issue2334 Guillaume Hoffmann
issue2343 Jose Luis Neder
issue2347 Guillaume Hoffmann

Patches applied (39)

See darcs wiki entry for details.

Darcs News #106

June 25, 2014 04:58 AM UTC

News and discussions

  1. Darcs is participating once again to the Google Summer of Code, through the umbrella organization Deadline for student application is Friday 21st:
  2. It is now possible to donate stock to darcs through the Software Freedom Conservancy organization. Donations by Paypal, Flattr, checks and wire transfer are still possible:
  3. Dan Licata wrote a presentation about Darcs as a higher inductive type:
  4. Darcs now directly provides import and export commands with Git. This code was adapted from Petr Rockai's darcs-fastconvert, with some changes by Owen Stephen from his Summer of Code project "darcs-bridge":

Issues resolved (6)

issue642 Jose Luis Neder
issue2209 Jose Luis Neder
issue2319 Guillaume Hoffmann
issue2332 Guillaume Hoffmann
issue2335 Guillaume Hoffmann
issue2348 Ryan

Patches applied (34)

See darcs wiki entry for details.

Darcs News #108

June 25, 2014 04:57 AM UTC

News and discussions

  1. We have a few updates from the Google Summer of Code projects. Alejandro Gadea about history reordering:
  2. Marcio Diaz about the cache system:
  3. Incremental fast-export is now provided to ease maintenance of git mirrors:

Issues resolved (8)

issue2244 Ale Gadea
issue2314 Benjamin Franksen
issue2361 Ale Gadea
issue2364 Sergei Trofimovich
issue2364 Sergei Trofimovich
issue2388 Owen Stephens
issue2394 Guillaume Hoffmann
issue2396 Guillaume Hoffmann

Patches applied (39)

See darcs wiki entry for details.